Friday, July 13, 2012

Physical analysis of Planet of the Apes

This was written by me as a freshman undergrad at Case Western Reserve University in 2006 for PHYS 123, Physics I Honors. It is reprinted in full, original form, with no attempt made to make the conclusion more realistic. Some of my assumptions were silly and made the problem trivial, but these were never graded for strict accuracy. 


In the context of the book The Planet of the Apes by Pierre Boulle (also a big-budget 1968 movie by Franklin J. Schaffner and starring Charlton Heston, and a more recent film), we see an early popular understanding of time dilation serve as a major plot device.  The relativity of time was used as a convenient method for allowing travel to a distant star system.  It was imagined in 1963, amidst frenzied advancement in astronomy, and so placed its opening timeframe perhaps only a few decades into the future.

Professor Antelle, a genius scientist, has invented a special spacecraft that is able to move at such a high velocity (via unknown propulsion) that time itself is slowed significantly for the pilot.  This obviates the problem of impossibly low interstellar speed, and allows a huge amount of space to be traversed in even “less” time (from the pilot’s point of view) due to time dilation.  Ulysses, the main character, is part of the expedition, along with the professor, and Levain, a physician. 
Time dilation versus velocity
They intend to use this spaceship to travel to the nearest place they believe that extraterrestrial life may exist- a star system whereof the supergiant Betelgeuse is the local sun.  The time it would take their ship to reach there is 350 years, but for the individuals inside, the time will feel like a mere two years.  What velocity does this entail?  Rearranging the above equation for known values:
In order for time dilation to be that potent, one must get very close to the speed of light.  As we can see, earthly technology brings us nowhere close to even this velocity which would only shrink time by a factor of 175.  In order to reach space millions or billions of light-years away, the only possibility is to get even closer to the speed of light.
The practical difficulty is not so much in what a person would do for years on a spaceship (although this is a bit mind-boggling) but the quantity of energy it would take to transport anything at speeds close to that of light.  The kinetic energy of an object traveling at the speed of light is phenomenal.  The craft described in the book is not miniscule, either.  Let us say, for example, that using miraculous miniaturization technologies that the spacecraft can be able to carry its engines, three passengers, and enough supplies for two years forward, two years back- in a mass no greater than that of the Space Shuttle.
This figure is a bit large, to say the least.  If this spaceship spread out its acceleration over the ridiculously long interval of 20 days, then the power required would be:
which is equal to 3.8 billion horsepower.  If it were to accelerate to that speed in the same time that it took for the Shuttle to clear the atmosphere, then over one trillion horsepower would be required. 

            The conclusion I draw from this is that, in order for humans to attain speeds close to that of light, the mass involved must be infinitesimal enough so that the energy can be produced to power it, or else new methods of power (e.g. not derived from chemical or electrical propulsion) must be found. 
            But audiences would never have suspected this in the optimistic year of 1963, and as The Planet of the Apes shows, it was not a picnic when the light-speed travelers arrived at their destination.  Society involved the subjugation of humans by their primate overlords.  When our hero Ulysse finally fled, and returned to Earth, 700 years had passed and the same fate of human enslavement had befallen his planet.
            The moral of the story, if one can be said to exist, was stated aptly by a student in Physics 123 on the day of the relativity lecture: “Stay the hell away from the speed of light.”


No comments:

Post a Comment